Votre activité
  • Home
    • News
    • Strategic perspectives
      • Perspective / 01
      • Perspective / 02
    • How we work
    • Our Experts
    • Our experience
    • Contact
    • About Arcana Alta®
Capture-d-ecran-2026-11-15-a-17-12-24

Europe's Missing Strategic Resource: Executive Capacity
Why strategic ambition alone cannot deliver industrial sovereignty.


Arcana Alta® | Strategic Perspectives

By Eric Dusseux, November 2026

Beyond strategic ambition

What if Europe's greatest strategic vulnerability was not a shortage of critical raw materials, capital or technology, but a shortage of executive capacity?

Europe possesses considerable scientific expertise, industrial capabilities, financial resources and diplomatic influence. It has developed ambitious industrial strategies, regulatory frameworks, funding instruments and international partnerships.

Yet the ability to mobilise these assets collectively and translate them into operational outcomes remains a fundamental challenge.

During my participation as a panellist and jury member at European Defence Week in Paris in November 2026, I explored several dimensions of Europe's industrial and strategic sovereignty.

One of the arguments I put forward during the panel discussion was that the most powerful negotiating asset for securing a critical mineral might have nothing to do with mining.

I developed this perspective in a previous Arcana Alta® Strategic Perspective, The Hidden Power of Cross-Sector Economic Diplomacy.

But negotiating leverage is only one part of the equation.

The real challenge is translating strategic leverage into sustainable industrial outcomes.

Coordination is not execution

Coordination works particularly well when stakeholders share objectives, incentives and timelines.

But what happens when they do not?

Governments may prioritise national industrial interests. Investors may seek attractive risk-adjusted returns. Industrial buyers may favour competitive prices and contractual flexibility. Security authorities may prioritise continuity of supply, irrespective of short-term economics.

Each position can be individually rational while producing a collectively suboptimal outcome.

Organisations often respond to such situations by creating additional committees, consultation mechanisms or coordination structures.

These mechanisms can improve transparency and mutual understanding. However, they do not necessarily resolve the fundamental question of who has the authority to make a decision when interests diverge.

Coordination connects stakeholders. Executive capacity makes collective decisions actionable, even when interests diverge.

The distinction is particularly important when decisions require significant financial commitments, involve uncertain outcomes or generate consequences across multiple sectors.

Gallium: a strategic vulnerability that illustrates the challenge

Consider a hypothetical major disruption in European gallium supplies.

According to the US Geological Survey's Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026, China accounts for approximately 99% of global primary low-purity gallium production.

Gallium-based semiconductor technologies play an important role in advanced electronics, telecommunications, radar systems and defence applications.

The International Energy Agency's Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2026 also highlights the supply risks associated with highly concentrated critical mineral value chains.

Securing gallium requires more than access to the raw material. It requires appropriate processing, purification, industrial qualification and integration into manufacturing value chains.

Europe has already initiated an institutional response to such challenges.

The European Commission's RESourceEU Action Plan, presented in December 2025, sets out plans for a European Critical Raw Materials Centre inspired by Japan's JOGMEC.

This initiative offers an opportunity to move beyond strategic intelligence towards a more integrated executive capability.

But what would such a capability mean in practice?

Five decisions that matter

A major supply disruption would immediately raise five fundamental decision-making questions.

1. What to secure?

Which industrial vulnerabilities should be addressed first?

Not all dependencies have the same strategic significance, and not all industrial applications have the same capacity to absorb supply disruptions.

Prioritisation must therefore consider the criticality of industrial applications, the availability of substitutes, existing inventories, alternative suppliers and the time required to restore supply.

In the case of gallium, decision-makers would need to assess the relative vulnerability of different industrial applications, from telecommunications and power electronics to radar systems and defence.

The objective is not simply to secure a material, but to protect the industrial capabilities that depend upon it.

2. What to back?

Which industrial projects deserve priority support?

Strategic importance does not automatically translate into commercial viability.

A project may offer significant long-term benefits for European sovereignty while facing considerable technological, financial or operational risks.

Conversely, a commercially attractive project may contribute relatively little to reducing Europe's most critical vulnerabilities.

Consider two hypothetical gallium projects. One proposes recovering gallium from an existing alumina production facility. The other involves building a new processing and purification facility with greater long-term potential but higher development risks.

Which project should receive priority support, and under what conditions?

These competing considerations require explicit investment and industrial policy trade-offs.

Europe does not merely face a funding challenge. It also faces a bankability challenge.

Available capital does not automatically create investable industrial projects.

3. What to buy?

Which purchasing commitments could make alternative production capacity commercially viable?

European industrial demand is often distributed across multiple companies, sectors and countries.

Individually, potential customers may lack sufficient purchasing volumes or willingness to enter into long-term contracts.

Collectively, their demand could help support investment in new production, processing or recycling capabilities.

Aggregating voluntary industrial demand and structuring credible offtake commitments can therefore become powerful instruments of industrial development.

The European Union's Critical Raw Materials Act, adopted in 2024, already provides for a mechanism for demand aggregation and joint purchasing under Article 25.

The challenge is translating such mechanisms into commercially credible commitments capable of supporting long-term investment, while respecting competition rules and the responsibilities of participating companies.

Securing demand can be as important as financing supply.

4. What to negotiate?

Which international partnerships and cross-sector economic opportunities could secure alternative supplies?

As discussed in the previous Strategic Perspective, Europe's sources of economic leverage extend well beyond the sectors in which its vulnerabilities arise.

Industrial technologies, financing, infrastructure, market access and skills development could all contribute to broader resource partnerships.

A mineral-producing country seeking to develop its domestic processing industry may, for example, value access to European industrial technologies and financing as much as Europe values access to its resources.

The challenge is to identify mutually beneficial arrangements while assessing their wider economic and strategic consequences.

Negotiating a commitment is only the beginning. Its industrial and commercial implementation must also be credible.

5. When to intervene?

Who can activate contingency measures, accelerate an alternative project, reallocate resources or discontinue an intervention that no longer delivers its intended strategic value?

Strategic environments are dynamic.

Prices change. Technologies evolve. Geopolitical relationships deteriorate or improve. Industrial projects experience delays. Previously credible assumptions may no longer hold.

A sudden restriction on gallium exports could require decision-makers to reassess industrial inventories, accelerate the qualification of alternative suppliers or prioritise particular investments.

Conversely, a project previously considered strategic may experience persistent cost overruns, lose its prospective customers or prove unable to meet industrial qualification requirements.

Executive capacity therefore requires not only the ability to initiate action, but also the discipline to modify or terminate it.

Knowing when to stop supporting a project can be as strategically important as knowing when to initiate one.

These five questions are not simply analytical questions.

They are executive decisions.

Governance must work when interests diverge

Effective governance requires more than representation, consultation and stakeholder engagement.

It requires clear decision ownership, explicit mandates, access to resources, measurable objectives and mechanisms for accountability and reassessment.

This does not imply that all authority should be concentrated within a single institution.

Different decisions legitimately belong to different public authorities, financial institutions and industrial stakeholders. Trade policy, national security, investment decisions and commercial contracts operate under distinct legal and institutional frameworks.

But fragmentation of authority should not result in fragmentation of responsibility.

The challenge is to design an operating model that connects different decision rights into a coherent executive capability.

Such a model should establish:

  • Who is authorised to make each decision.
  • Which resources can be committed.
  • How competing strategic interests are assessed.
  • How disagreements are resolved or escalated.
  • Who is accountable for implementation.
  • Under which conditions decisions must be reassessed.

A European Critical Raw Materials Centre could provide an opportunity to explore such an operating model, within the limits of its future legal mandate and delegated responsibilities.

The objective would not be to create another layer of governance, but to establish effective ownership of strategic outcomes.

Governance should not merely be designed for situations in which stakeholders agree. It should also work when they disagree.

From artificial intelligence to decision intelligence

Emerging analytical and AI-enabled capabilities could help address another dimension of this challenge: the growing complexity of strategic decisions.

Securing a critical material may reduce one vulnerability while creating another.

Supporting an industrial project may improve long-term resilience while increasing short-term financial exposure.

An international agreement may generate opportunities in one sector while imposing costs elsewhere.

Traditional analytical approaches often assess these questions separately, making it difficult to understand their combined consequences.

Decision intelligence offers an opportunity to explore these interdependencies more systematically.

One promising concept is that of a decision twin: a dynamic analytical representation of a strategic environment that allows decision-makers to explore alternative scenarios, test assumptions and assess the potential consequences of different actions before committing resources.

Unlike a conventional dashboard, which primarily describes the current state of a system, a decision twin would seek to represent how that system might respond to different decisions.

In the context of critical raw materials, such an approach could help explore the potential consequences of:

  • A disruption in international supply.
  • A change in industrial demand.
  • A delay in the commissioning of a strategic processing facility.
  • A new long-term purchasing commitment.
  • A change in trade restrictions or geopolitical conditions.
  • A reallocation of investment or public financial support.

Such capabilities could support scenario analysis, identify second-order effects and establish conditions under which previous decisions should be reassessed.

Their reliability would depend on the quality of the underlying data, the robustness of the models and the explicit treatment of uncertainty.

Their purpose is not to replace human judgement or institutional accountability.

It is to improve the quality, consistency and adaptability of strategic decisions.

Artificial intelligence can expand our analytical capabilities. Decision intelligence must help us decide what to do with them.

Measuring execution rather than activity

A genuine executive capability must ultimately be evaluated through outcomes.

In the context of critical raw materials, the number of projects identified, partnerships announced, meetings organised or financial commitments made provides useful information.

But these indicators do not necessarily demonstrate an improvement in industrial resilience.

More meaningful performance measures would include:

  • Diversification of qualified suppliers.
  • Volumes secured through reliable purchasing commitments.
  • Industrial processing and manufacturing capacity brought into operation.
  • Reduction in the time required to recover from supply disruptions.
  • Reduction in exposure to geographical or corporate concentration risks.

The distinction is fundamental.

Activity measures what an organisation does.

Outcome measures reveal whether its interventions have made a difference.

The ultimate measure of strategic autonomy is not the amount of capital committed. It is the vulnerability effectively reduced.

Beyond European industrial sovereignty

This challenge extends well beyond critical raw materials.

Corporations navigating technological disruption, family businesses undergoing strategic transformation, investors supporting industrial scale-up and public institutions pursuing economic sovereignty all face a similar problem.

They must make consequential decisions in environments characterised by uncertainty, competing interests and interconnected risks.

Yet strategic intelligence, governance, capital allocation and operational execution are still too often treated as separate disciplines.

Their integration may become one of the most important sources of competitive and institutional advantage in an increasingly complex world.

At Arcana Alta®, we explore this intersection through strategic advisory, private diplomacy and executive education.

Our conviction is that effective leadership increasingly requires the ability to understand complex systems, identify unconventional sources of leverage, make difficult decisions and orchestrate their implementation.

Strategic ambition defines where we want to go.

Executive capacity determines whether we ever get there.

Further reading

Arcana Alta® Strategic Perspectives #01: The Hidden Power of Cross-Sector Economic Diplomacy.

Selected references

US Geological Survey (2026). Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026.

International Energy Agency (2026). Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2026.

European Union (2024). Critical Raw Materials Act, Regulation (EU) 2024/1252.

European Commission (2025). RESourceEU Action Plan, COM(2025) 945 final.

Japan Organization for Metals and Energy Security. JOGMEC.

About Arcana Alta®

Arcana Alta® operates at the intersection of strategic intelligence, private diplomacy and ecosystem building, supporting leaders and organisations through strategic advisory and executive education.

Subtle leverage. Tangible balance.

Home
Arcana-alta-originale-bleue-marine

contact@arcanaalta.com

     Arcana Alta®
is the executive education and leadership development brand of Concord EMDX Consulting,
an independent Paris-based advisory firm.

  • Home
    • News
    • Strategic perspectives
      • Perspective / 01
      • Perspective / 02
    • How we work
    • Our Experts
    • Our experience
    • Contact
    • About Arcana Alta®
Website created with